Meeting with the judiciary

  • 21
  • 18:39

There should be no contrivance or artificiality in the acts of the Constitutional Court, which have practical consequences and affect law enforcement, Belarusian President Aleksandr Lukashenko said at a meeting with the judiciary on 19 November.

Speaking about the significance of the Constitutional Court’s work, the head of state noted that its rulings influence not only legal doctrine but also have practical consequences. Above all, they affect law enforcement.

“Of course, there should be no artificiality or contrivance in the acts of the Constitutional Court. Nor should there be competition with the Supreme Court and other bodies. I would very much ask you to keep this in mind,” the Belarusian leader said.

“We adopted a new edition of the Constitution, the people supported it, and the Constitutional Court received extensive powers. This is not only about interpreting the Fundamental Law, reviewing the constitutionality of elections and exercising preliminary control over international treaties. We have reached a new level in protecting the rights and freedoms of citizens by introducing the institution of direct constitutional complaint,” Aleksandr Lukashenko stressed.

The President noted that people turn to the Constitutional Court with real problems that matter to them - housing, property rights, being held administratively liable. “This means the institution is in demand among the population. In such cases, you effectively put an end to a person’s dispute with the law. And here the issues of preserving socio-political and social balance come to the fore,” he stressed. “That is why the demands on you are also high. If every judge meets such expectations, the supreme constitutional body will not turn into just another instance for reviewing court cases.”

The President also spoke about the implementation of Constitutional Court decisions and rulings on laws that do not conform to the Constitution, as well as other rough edges in legislation. “Their consideration is the direct duty of the bodies, organizations and officials to whom they are addressed by the Constitutional Court. And I don’t think that in this part we yet need any harsh measures or a special procedure. We have a working parliament and government, and a system exists. We need to work in this direction,” Aleksandr Lukashenko said.

The head of state noted that the Constitutional Court, in its new status and composition, has already taken a firmly established place in the current system of power. “We will see later; perhaps something will need to be adjusted in our legislation as well. We will not rush,” the President said. 

“Special attention must be paid to the practice of law enforcement. You are at the forefront of this work; it is you who see the real gaps, conflicts, and inconsistencies in legal acts. If you believe that legislation is in some way unjust, contradictory, or does not meet reality, it is your direct duty to raise the issue of changing it,” Aleksandr Lukashenko stated. “Perhaps you do not fully realize it, but it is you who seriously influence not only all elements of the legal system (prosecutors, investigators, lawyers, legal practitioners), but also the executive authorities.”

The head of state noted that tax officials, economists, agricultural workers, and all sectors of the economy and social sector rely on court decisions. “The entire law enforcement practice is based on your decisions. Therefore, related agencies, especially the law enforcement, expect you to step up the work of the plenum and update its rulings. They note that on a number of complex issues there are no clarifications at all. It turns out that everyone applies the law as they understand it. This must not be the case. Here we need to think about linking your work with the Constitutional Court,” the Belarusian leader stated.

“I understand that the independence of judges is a constant. At the same time, you are fully bound by the law, rely on it, and obey it,” Aleksandr Lukashenko said. “Can judges hide from the people behind a wall of law, following the logic of the well-known Latin maxim, ‘Let justice be done, though the world perish’? No, that is not our way, not our mentality.”

“If the world develops according to the laws of justice, I think it will never perish. Judges of both general jurisdiction and the Constitutional Court, like no one else, must understand their role in this context. Especially today, when the demand for justice, social security, and safety is so high. Look at what is happening around us. Yet our legal reforms meet the challenges set by the times. At least we didn't make the same foolish mistake we're seeing today among our Polish neighbors,” the head of state emphasized.

“It is important to remember that in current conditions, of particular importance is the legal protection of Belarusian business entities and the state against the consequences of various illegitimate sanctions. Investment attractiveness is one of the most important priorities for the development of any country. Investors can count on reliable judicial protection of their interests in Belarus. But on one condition: if they work honestly and do not confuse economics with politics,” Aleksandr Lukashenko said.

In this connection, the head of state drew attention to the serious changes that have taken place in the system of courts of general jurisdiction. The Appellate Economic Court has started its work, and a single Code of Civil Procedure for the judicial system is being put into effect. “The decisions taken were balanced and well-considered. In principle, no significant shortcomings are apparent,” he said.